The large-scale environment is thought to play an important role in setting galaxy properties. The Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) reside in the Local Group, embedded in the Local Sheet (LS). To study the sheet's influence on the dark matter (DM) halo shapes, spins, and disks orientations of MW and M31 analogues, we use a new suite of constrained Local Group simulations that reproduce the observed configuration of the two main halos and the LS. We determine their shapes and alignments relative to the LS analogues, and the effect of infall and coalescence of massive mergers. We find that the DM halo shapes of our MW and M31 analogues are on average slightly rounder than literature reports for similar-mass galaxies in random environments. We find preferential alignment between the sheet normal and the halos' minor axes, but not with the halos' spins. The present-day disk angular momenta ($L_{\rm disk}$) closely align with the halos' minor axes (median $15^{+15}_{-8}$ degrees at $R_{\rm vir}$) and with the halos' spins. The direction of $L_{\rm disk}$ is often set by one of the two highest mass ratio mergers during the last 8-10 Gyr. While recent ($\leq 2$ Gyr) massive mergers can reorient the outer halo's minor axis leading to twisted shapes, $L_{\rm disk}$ retains the imprint of the earlier accretion event. These results can explain the peculiar alignment of the MW's disk and DM halo shape and their orientation relative to the LS. The prolate-like morphology and orientation of the MW's outer halo can be explained by the Magellanic Clouds (and perhaps Sagittarius) accreting from within the LS. As their orbital planes are nearly perpendicular to the Galactic disk, the disk orientation must be set earlier, possibly by the GES merger. This merger's estimated infall direction, highly inclined relative to the present-day LS, is broadly consistent with the LS's direction of maximum collapse.